CBC workstream in support of
Auditing in complex and challenging contexts (ACCC)
In line with INTOSAI’s crosscutting priorities and the strategic objectives defined for the CBC in the INTOSAI Strategic Plan 2017-2022, the project group in support of auditing in complex and challenging contexts works to achieve CBC’s key strategy 7:
Focus attention on SAIs in fragile situations with particular emphasis on the impact of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development on their capacity development needs.
The CBC will, through this workstream, lead INTOSAI’s efforts to identify what support is needed and good practices to address those needs, adjusted to the preconditions of SAIs auditing in complex and challenging contexts and the organizations supporting them.
The CBC aims to develop different methods and approaches to support public sector auditing in complex and challenging contexts as well as donors and partner organizations supporting development in this area. This may include both awareness raising and knowledge sharing and the provision of more practical advice and guidance.
About the workstream
SAIs in fragile contexts were initially discussed at the CBC annual meeting in Lima, Peru in 2014, at the initiative of CREFIAF. As a result of those discussions, a small task group was set up to explore the issues and propose a way forward. That task group consisted of representatives from the SAIs of the Netherlands, Sierra Leone, the United Kingdom and Sweden, and from the IDI. Their work resulted in the creation of a workstream, which includes the SAIs of Afghanistan, Liberia, Netherlands, Norway, Sierra Leone, Sudan and Sweden, as well as IDI, as members.
The initial terms of reference was approved by the CBC Steering Committee during the CBC Annual Meeting in Cape Town in October 2016 and endorsed by INCOSAI in Abu Dhabi two months later. The priorities of the workstream are based on experiences by SAIs currently or previously working in states in different levels of fragility, and by donors and partners working with SAIs in such contexts. The experiences have been collected through a selection of interviews and discussions as well as reports and articles.
The work stream held its first meeting in conjunction with the CBC meeting in Washington D.C. in September 2017 and now holds regular skype meetings.
A revised terms of reference was approved by the CBC Steering Committee during its meeting in Kuwait in 2018.
Activities and results
First ACCC webinar – “Building trust of Governments – and keeping it”
Yusador Gaye, Auditor General of Liberia, lead the first webinar on behalf of the CBC workstream Auditing in Complex and Challenging Contexts (ACCC). The webinar was recorded to enable others to benefit from the discussion. You will find the link to the recording, as well as the powerpoint and notes from the presentation here:
The ACCC workstream aims to help two or three webinars per year on topics of particular relevance for SAIs in complex and challenging contexts.
The workstream invited Auditors General, Deputy Auditors General and some staff from Zimbabwe, South Africa, South Sudan, Palestine and Rwanda, and CEO and staff from AFROSAI-E, to a forum in Johannesburg, South Africa, 28-29 March, 2018. Please find the summary report from the forum here: Johannesburg forum – final report.
Please find the first workstream paper here: State building in fragile situations.
The workstream has adopted a work plan and has shared the responsibility for the different activities among the workstream members. The group is assisted by David Goldsworthy of Development Action Ltd. UK, when developing the work in some of the activities.
David Goldsworthy has developed a draft discussion paper for the workstream regarding the implementation of ISSAIs in challenging and complex situations Implementing the ISSAIs in challenging and complex contexts – discussion paper. Anyone wishing to share experiences of both challenges and successes in the implementation of ISSAIs are welcome to contact the workstream.
INTOSAI members interested in contributing to the workstream are invited to contact SAI Sweden, Oskar Karnebäck: email@example.com or Johanna Gårdmark: firstname.lastname@example.org.
Minutes of workstream meetings
05 December 2018: Draft minutes CBC workstream ACCC telephone meeting
24 October 2018: Draft minutes CBC workstream ACCC telephone meeting
03 September 2018: Draft minutes CBC workstream SAIs in Fragile Situations, Kuwait
29 May 2018: Minutes CBC workstream SAIs in Fragile Situations – and discussion paper: Issues to consider in deciding to change the name of the workstream
20 March 2018: Minutes CBC workstream SAIs in Fragile Situations
16 January 2018: Minutes CBC Work Stream SAIs in Fragile Situations
24 October 2017: Minutes skype meeting CBC work stream SAIs in Fragile Situations
29 September 2017: Minutes CBC work stream SAIs in fragile situations meeting Washington DC
Documents - Progress reports
Lines of Action/ Work Plan
The workstream has adopted a work plan. Responsibility for the different activities is shared among the workstream members.
Some of the activities in the work plan are supported by a separate activity plan:
According to the terms of reference, the CBC aims to develop different methods and approaches to support SAIs in complex and challenging contexts as well as donors and partner organizations working with them. This may include both awareness raising and knowledge sharing and the provision of more practical advice and guidance.
Potential outputs may, for example, include:
- Lessons learned and case studies based on experiences of SAIs and/or their development partners;
- Good practice guidance for SAIs auditing in complex and challenging contexts, their partner SAIs/organizations, INTOSAI regions and donors;
- Materials and models to support SAIs in identifying first step- and next step solutions to challenges identified;
- Development of training materials for SAI staff and consultants engaged in, or planning to engage in change agent roles with SAIs auditing in complex and challenging contexts for use by providers of support;
- An open dialogue and sharing of experiences between the SAIs concerned and between their partners and donors, respectively.
Swedish National Audit Office (lead)
Supreme Audit Office of Afghanistan
General Auditing Commission, Liberia
Netherlands Court of Audit
Office of the Auditor General of Norway
Audit Service Sierra Leone
National Audit Chamber of Sudan
INTOSAI Development Initiative
For further information, please contact Oskar Karnebäck at the Swedish National Audit Office: email@example.com.
All CBC members and stakeholders are kindly reminded to save the date for the next contiguous CBC/IDC meeting taking place in Tokyo on 1-4 July, 2019. 1-3 July: CBC meeting (3)-4 July: IDC meeting All necessary information regarding meeting registration, hotel...
Representatives from eight EUROSAI member SAIs and the IDI met over three days, 12-14 February, in the Hague to share experiences of peer-to-peer cooperation. With an ambition to improve quality of delivery and increase the quantity of peer providers, colleagues...
France’s Cour des comptes (Court of Accounts) hosts the General Secretariat of the Association of Supreme Audit Institutions (SAIs) having the use of French in common (AISCCUF). Since the association was created in 1994, its main objective has been to help strengthen...
The CBC Chair, on behalf of the the Task Force on INTOSAI Auditor Professionalisation (TFIAP), invites the INTOSAI community to comment on the draft Pathways Guide and the updated Competency Framework. Please find Mr Kimi Makwetu's letter here: Invitation to comment...
In the recently published winter edition of the INTOSAI Journal we are happy to find several inspiring stories relevant to the CBC, and we encourage you to go ahead and find the pages covering Good Stories of the ACCC (Auditing in Complex and Challenging Contexts) (p...
There are many ways in which peers learn from and support each other. During the CBC annual meeting in Kuwait in 2018 discussions were held relating to medium and long-term peer-to-peer cooperation with the purpose of developing the capacities and capabilities of the...
Yusador Gaye, Auditor General of Liberia, lead the first webinar on behalf of the CBC workstream Auditing in Complex and Challenging Contexts (ACCC). The topic, “Building trust of Governments – and keeping it”, was identified as an issue of common interest during the...
Please find the draft minutes from the CBC Steering Committee meeting in Kuwait among other post-meeting documentation, right here: https://www.intosaicbc.org/post-meeting-documentation/.
The first CBC guide to be revised, "Building capacity in SAIs", has now been replaced by the new "Strengthening of SAIs - a guide for improving performance" and is available in the CBC document library. The revision has been carried out by the external consultant...
The INTOSAI Governing Board met in Moscow on 15-16 November. The CBC Vice Chair, Magnus Lindell, reported on progress made by the CBC and its workstreams in relation to the CBC workplan and the INTOSAI Strategic Plan. The summary (INTOSAI Governing Board 2018...